Claims and Payments Erie Insurance Claims: 800-367-3743 Payments: 800-458-0811 Celina Insurance Claims: 800-231-2318 Payments: 855-586-2911 Pekin Insurance Claims: 888-735-4611 Payments: 800-322-0160 Encompass Claims: 800-588-7400 Payments: 866-430-2916 Foremost Claims: 800-527-3907 Payments: 888-888-0080 National General Claims: 800-468-3466 Payments: 877-468-3466 Humana Claims: 800-457-4708 Payments: 800-457-4708 Progressive Claims: 800-776-4737: Option 1 Payments: 800-776-4737: Option Hagerty Claims: 877-922-9701 Payments: 888-220-9565 Bristol West Claims: 877-649-6682 Payments: 877-649-6682 Westfield Claims: 800-243-0210 Payments: 800-766-9133 American Modern Claims: 800-375-2075 Payments: 800-543-2644 Openly Claims: 888-808-4842 Payments Anthem Claims: 833-959-1531 Payments: 833-959-1531 Aetna Claims: 800-587-5139 Payments Western Reserve Group Claims: 800-362-0426 Payments: 800-362-0426
